Insurance fraud schemes often involve carefully timed policy changes and misrepresented loss details, making thorough investigations essential to protecting insurance programs and policyholders.

Floods can turn a normal day into a stressful one in a matter of hours. Vehicles can be damaged, roads can become impassable, and the cost of repairs can add up quickly. That’s why auto insurance is there to help when the unexpected happens. But sometimes, a claim raises an important question: Did the damage occur before coverage was in place?

That’s exactly what happened in a recent case that took Maryland Auto’s Special Investigation Unit (SIU) all the way to Atlantic City, New Jersey.

The claim involved a vehicle that was reported as a flood loss during a major coastal storm at the end of September. At first, the story seemed straightforward. The policyholder said she had traveled to Atlantic City for a family birthday celebration and while there, her vehicle was damaged by floodwaters. But as investigators reviewed the details, the timeline started to get murky.

The policy had lapsed for more than a month before it was reinstated. Coverage became effective on a day of severe flooding in Atlantic City. The following day, the policyholder added physical damage coverage, rental reimbursement, and towing. One day later, the flood damage claim was reported. When additional coverage levels are added to an existing policy so close to a claim, it can be a fraud indicator or flag.

To get a clearer picture, SIU dove deeper.

Investigators reviewed weather reports, toll records, witness statements, videos, and even text messages. During a recorded interview, the location where the vehicle was parked changed from the one initially reported. Investigators also found messages showing the policyholder asking about flood insurance before the policy was purchased.

SIU traveled to Atlantic City and spoke with residents who lived near the reported loss location. Several witnesses recalled the date that the area had been flooded, it turned out to be before the policy became effective. In addition, a Maryland Auto claims supervisor who lives near Atlantic City confirmed for the investigators that the day the coverage was reinstated was the day of the worst flooding. Investigators also obtained videos showing the specific avenue where the incident was reported under several feet of water the night before coverage for the vehicle began and again the following morning.

The evidence ultimately pointed to the determination that the vehicle had sustained flood damage before the policy became active.

As a result, the claim was denied and referred to the Insurance Fraud Division (IFD) and the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB).

This case is a good reminder that insurance investigations often involve much more than reviewing a claim form. Weather data, digital communications, witness interviews, and video evidence can all help investigators determine exactly what happened and when it happened.

In Maryland, insurance fraud can lead to both criminal and civil penalties. When someone files a fraudulent claim, everyone pays the price through higher insurance costs. That’s why Maryland Auto’s SIU works closely with our Claims team to identify suspicious fraud indicators and protect the premiums of our policyholders.

Uncategorized